Does it not seem as if things were fluid?

[Dots between square brackets indicate cuts made by Sir Sidney Colvin. For full, correct and critical edition of this letter, see Mehew 1, 168].

To his mother [Colvin 1911, pp. 96-98]

Hôtel du Pavillon, Menton, November 13, 1873.

My dear Mother,

[…] The Place is not where I thought; it is about where the old Post Office was. The Hôtel de Londres is no more an hotel. I have found a charming room in the Hôtel du Pavillon,

The Hôtel du Pavillon, Menton, as seen from South-East, late 19th century.

just across the road from the Prince’s Villa;

Palais Carnolés, Menton, 2005.
Palais Carnolès, the “Prince’s Villa”, as seen from the former Hôtel du Pavillon, 2005.

it has one window to the south and one to the east, with a superb view of Mentone and the hills, to which I move this afternoon. […]

The Hôtel du Pavillon, now Prince de Galles, Menton, 2005.
East corner of the Hôtel Prince de Galles, former Hôtel du Pavillon, Menton, 2005.

In the old great Place there is a kiosque for the sale of newspapers; a string of omnibuses (perhaps thirty) go up and down under the plane-trees of the Turin Road on the occasion of each train;

Omnibus and carts at the railway station, Menton, late 19th century [https://lh3.googleusercontent.com0]

the Promenade has crossed both streams, and bids fair to reach the Cap St. Martin.

The Promenade du Midi, Menton, 1905 []
Promenade du Midi, Menton, early 19th century

The old chapel near Freeman’s house at the entrance to the Gorbio valley is now entirely submerged under a shining new villa, with pavilion annexed; over which, in all the pride of oak and chestnut and divers coloured marbles, I was shown this morning by the obliging proprietor. The Prince’s Palace itself is rehabilitated, and shines afar with white window-curtains from the midst of a garden, all trim borders and greenhouses and carefully kept walks.

Palais Carnolès, the “Prince’s Palace”, old summer residence of the Grimaldis, in front of the former Hôtel du Pavillon, Menton, 2005.
Carnolès Gardens, Menton []

On the other side, the villas are more thronged together, and they have arranged themselves, shelf after shelf, behind each other. I see the glimmer of new buildings, too, as far eastward as Grimaldi;

Menton, as seen from Grimaldi, Ventimiglia []

and a viaduct carries (I suppose) the railway past the mouth of the bone caves.

The ‘bone caves’ (Grimaldi Caves, Barzi Rossi, Red Cliffs), to the east of Menton (M. Rivière phot. and Sorrieu engr.) []
The ‘bone caves’, Menton []

F. Bacon (Lord Chancellor) made the remark that ‘Time was the greatest innovator’; it is perhaps as meaningless a remark as was ever made; but as Bacon made it, I suppose it is better than any that I could make.

Francis Bacon, 1st Viscount St Alban (1561–1626), English philosopher and statesman who served as Attorney General and as Lord Chancellor of England []

Does it not seem as if things were fluid? They are displaced and altered in ten years so that one has difficulty, even with a memory so very vivid and retentive for that sort of thing as mine, in identifying places where one lived a long while in the past, and which one has kept piously in mind during all the interval. Nevertheless, the hills, I am glad to say, are unaltered;

Cl. Monet, Menton vu du Cap Martin, 1884 []

though I dare say the torrents have given them many a shrewd scar, and the rains and thaws dislodged many a boulder from their heights, if one were only keen enough to perceive it. The sea makes the same noise in the shingle;

Plage des Sablettes, Menton []

and the lemon and orange gardens still discharge in the still air their fresh perfume;

Menton Lemon Festival, held in February []

and the people have still brown comely faces;

‘Menton – Une limoneuse’ []
Washerwoman, Menton, 1906 []

and the Pharmacie Gros still dispenses English medicines; and the invalids (eheu!) still sit on the promenade and trifle with their fingers in the fringes of shawls and wrappers;


and the shop of Pascal Amarante still, in its present bright consummate flower of aggrandisement and new paint, offers everything that it has entered into people’s hearts to wish for in the idleness of a sanatorium;

Flat straw hat by Pascal Amarante, milliner, c. 1870 []
Pascal Amarante, carte de visite albumine, Menton, c. 1880 []

and the ‘Château des Morts’ is still at the top of the town;

Château des Morts, Menton []
View of Menton with the Château des Morts on top of the hill, 2005.

and the fort and the jetty are still at the foot, only there are now two jetties; and – I am out of breath. (To be continued in our next.)

The Fort, Menton, 2005.
J.F. Raffaelli, ‘The jetty, Menton’, 1890 []

For myself, I have come famously through the journey; and as I have written this letter (for the first time for ever so long) with ease and even pleasure, I think my head must be better. I am still no good at coming down hills or stairs; and my feet are more consistently cold than is quite comfortable. But, these apart, I feel well; and in good spirits all round.

I have written to Nice for letters, and hope to get them to-night. Continue to address Poste Restante. Take care of yourselves.

This is my birthday, by the way – O, I said that before. Adieu. – Ever your affectionate son,

R.L. Stevenson

This entry was posted in Letters, Robert Louis Stevenson and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.